How we grade
One pair, one honest grade.
Every pair on Prime Soles goes through the same 30+ point inspection before it's listed. We don't use stock photos or generic descriptions — the grade on each product page describes exactly what to expect from that exact pair.
Premium+
As close to new as thrift gets. Unworn or worn only a handful of times, with nothing to point out.
- No visible creasing, scuffing, or discoloration, inside or out
- Sole and tread essentially full — looks straight off the shelf
- The rarest grade in our inventory
Premium
Lightly worn with only the faintest signs of use. A step below Premium+, still exceptional.
- Barely-there creasing, visible only up close
- Sole and tread in excellent shape
- Deep-cleaned and conditioned before listing
Looks and feels great. Only the closest inspection reveals it's pre-owned.
- Minor creasing consistent with light wear
- Sole and tread in strong shape, freshly deep-cleaned by us before listing
- A reliable everyday grade with no real compromises
Gently worn with only minor, honest signs of use. Clean and ready to wear.
- Light creasing or a small cosmetic mark at most
- No structural issues — upper, sole, and lining all sound
- Sanitized and conditioned before photographing
Good
Comfortable, well-loved pairs with visible wear from regular use — priced to match.
- Noticeable creasing, scuffing, or fading consistent with regular wear
- Still structurally solid and comfortable to wear
- Our best value grade for everyday rotation
Every grade is backed by our inspection.
If a pair ever arrives in worse condition than listed, reach out and we'll make it right.